John try reluctant to obfuscate the problem even this much in the Sherlock’s presence. John allows Sherlock faith he or she is straight, however, he never shuts you to home entirely: odd choices having a great heterosexual son, but surely reasonable to possess good bisexual kid that’s in search of a love that have Sherlock and dreams Sherlock you’ll transform their attention. And even though John can’t ever knowingly state “I am not saying homosexual” within earshot out of Sherlock, Sherlock does overhear John point out that to help you Irene into the An effective Scandal for the Belgravia – then John tries to features a discussion about it with Sherlock, which can be turn off.
Really, for one thing, Sherlock appeared to really dislike the thought of John becoming drawn in order to him. It’s a good idea John perform only big date women to keep Sherlock out of acquiring the perception. Think of, John try willing to kill visitors to remain near Sherlock, thus obviously he’d become ready to hide their sexuality also. Together with, in the event the John tried to go out males they might assume he had been looking Sherlock, not unfairly. It will make many feel for John at this point lady, and he will not appear to have a problem with they. (Even if, to get reasonable, which have John you can never be sure.) It is quite easy to own bisexual individuals alive heterosexual lifetime: many people are heterosexual and you will imagine everyone else is also, thus heterosexual matchmaking opportunities pop-up without the need to end up being wanted aside.
However, as to the reasons was not John already open about any of it, and why do he obfuscate the challenge to his aunt and you may Costs Murray? Better, you will find hints in order to so much more explanations within these early blog site records. John is also known as a females kid before getting mailed out so you can Afghanistan, along with The hallmark of About three we have been demonstrated the character regarding Big Sholto, a guy who John considerably admires and has now a few of the exact same unsociable functions Sherlock has; most likely large friends ekÅŸi the custodian during the John try drawn to people that see psychologically wounded and you can skittish.
And then make a joke about the indisputable fact that John was gay was not the absolute most delicate ecosystem they may has actually developed in the event the John wished to emerge
Along with broader words, it would be unsurprising when the John’s homosexual front involved the fresh fore as he was at the army and mostly in the middle of males – and even, throughout the Sign of Three we shall be provided with significant gay contacts on the armed forces, and you may Major Sholto in particular. Together with, this new let you know often reinforce more than once one to sex try crucial that you John. When the John has any destination at all to help you men, it is far from unreasonable to believe he’d act inside in an enthusiastic environment where there have been couple offered female.
By far the most telling question, yet not, is the fact John’s audience of these “I am not saying gay” minutes is not Sherlock, even despite the fact Sherlock imagine John was hitting toward him in the 1st episode and folks continually imagine these include two
So what took place in Afghanistan? We do not learn, but it is not really difficult to imagine. Maybe John don’t get to work on it, and he doesn’t can select. Maybe it was unrequited, in which he seems sad otherwise bitter contemplating unsociable males. Possibly it was requited and you can ended poorly. Perhaps he performed operate in it however, there was pressure in order to ensure that it stays secret and you can, having just returned from the battle, he isn’t really yes how exactly to begin becoming unlock regarding they given their early in the day character along with his old members of the family getting weird about it – maybe not a rare issue just in case you appear later on inside the existence, and you will Statement and Harry appear to get the idea funny. Or perhaps John advised themselves it absolutely was only because people were not offered, however, he is starting to understand possibly it absolutely was more you to. Possibly the guy has a tendency to like females, and you will males need certainly to really be a present. Perhaps the guy desires youngsters; John seems delighted sufficient as he learns regarding Mary’s pregnancy in the The unmistakeable sign of About three. It isn’t anyway unusual getting bisexual guys for intercourse that have people but merely follow dating with females therefore.